Is it ok to blend whole fruit into smoothies?
There is so much nonsense about fruit and blood sugar on social media and in pop nutrition books.
Multiple studies have proven that blending fruit into smoothies does NOT cause bigger blood sugar spikes than eating whole fruit.
In fact, these studies show that blending fruit into smoothies actually lowers the glycemic index, compared to an equivalent amount of whole fruit.
Why?
Because when you blend fruit into smoothies, it causes the soluble fiber naturally present in the fruit to bind more strongly to the sugar that is also naturally present in the fruit. This slows the absorption of the sugar in your intestinal tract, leading to a lower impact on blood glucose.
Quoted from reference [1]:
“While increased intake of dietary fiber is known to reduce postprandial glycemic response, it is less understood whether the disruption of dietary fiber, in a blender, alters the postprandial glycemic response. We compared the postprandial glycemic response in 20 young, healthy college students (12 female, 8 male) after consuming whole fruit vs. blended fruit.”
“Glucose maximum and glucose iAUC were significantly lower (p < 0.05) in blended fruit compared to whole fruit and 60 min glucose was marginally significantly lower (p = 0.057) in blended fruit compared to whole fruit.”
Quoted from reference [2]:
“Although whole-fruit consumption is regarded as protective against type 2 diabetes (T2DM), conventionally prepared fruit juice is associated with increased T2DM risk, and current public health advice recommends its restriction. 'Nutrient extractor' style blenders are increasing in popularity worldwide as an alternative means of juicing fruit, but little is known about their effect on postprandial glucose levels. The current study investigated the effect of nutrient extraction on postprandial blood glucose response and glycemic index (GI) compared with a glucose control for both mixed fruit and a high GI fruit (mango). Remarkably, consumption of nutrient-extracted mixed fruit resulted in a significant lowering of the GI (32.7±8.5) compared with whole mixed fruit (66.2±8.2, P<0.05).”
Quoted from reference [3]:
“Fruit consumption is recommended as part of a healthy diet. However, consumption of fruit in the form of juice is positively associated with type 2 diabetes risk, possibly due to resulting hyperglycemia. In a recent study, fruit juice prepared by nutrient extraction, a process that retains the fiber component, was shown to elicit a favorable glycemic index (GI), compared to eating the fruit whole, in healthy weight adults. The current study expanded on this to include individuals with obesity, and assessed whether the nutrient extraction of seeded fruits reduced GI in a higher disease risk group. Nutrient extraction was shown to significantly lower GI, compared to eating fruit whole, in subjects with obesity.”
Quoted from reference [4]:
“This investigation examined the metabolic and performance effects of ingesting solid compared to slurried carbohydrate food (bananas) between two prolonged exhaustive exercise bouts.”
“The mean glucose concentration from the SL treatment did not differ significantly from the SO treatment.”
References:
1
Paper · Nutrients · 2022Postprandial Glycemic Response to Whole Fruit versus Blended Fruit in Healthy, Young Adults.While increased intake of dietary fiber is known to reduce postprandial glycemic response, it is less understood whether the disruption of dietary fiber, in a blender, alters the postprandial glycemic response. We compared the postprandial glycemic response in 20 young, healthy college students (12 female, 8 male) after consuming whole fruit vs. blended fruit. The fruit included gala apple, with the seeds removed,…pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov2
Paper · Nutr Diabetes · 2017Nutrient-extraction blender preparation reduces postprandial glucose responses from fruit juice consumption.Although whole-fruit consumption is regarded as protective against type 2 diabetes (T2DM), conventionally prepared fruit juice is associated with increased T2DM risk, and current public health advice recommends its restriction. 'Nutrient extractor' style blenders are increasing in popularity worldwide as an alternative means of juicing fruit, but little is known about their effect on postprandial glucose levels. The…pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov3
Paper · Nutrients · 2020Nutrient Extraction Lowers Postprandial Glucose Response of Fruit in Adults with Obesity as well as Healthy Weight Adults.Fruit consumption is recommended as part of a healthy diet. However, consumption of fruit in the form of juice is positively associated with type 2 diabetes risk, possibly due to resulting hyperglycemia. In a recent study, fruit juice prepared by nutrient extraction, a process that retains the fiber component, was shown to elicit a favorable glycemic index (GI), compared to eating the fruit whole, in healthy weight…pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov4
Paper · Int J Sport Nutr · 1993Differences in the effects of carbohydrate food form on endurance performance to exhaustion.This investigation examined the metabolic and performance effects of ingesting solid compared to slurried carbohydrate food (bananas) between two prolonged exhaustive exercise bouts. Eight highly trained male triathletes performed four exhaustive endurance tests (ET), each separated by at least 2 weeks. Each ET consisted of a 90-min run followed by 90 min of cycling, both at 70% VO2max. Workloads were then gradually…pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov————-
#fruitHD #smoothiesHD #glycemicindexHD
#influencersHD #bananasHD #glucoseHD #blendingfruitHD
