A recently published meta-analysis of randomized trials concludes that machines are just as effective at promoting muscle growth as free weights.
For older people, machines may be safer.
A systematic review and meta-analysis by Haugen and colleagues compared free weights with machines and found similar muscle growth. Only five studies qualified, and the poster notes that machines may be safer for older people.
A recently published meta-analysis of randomized trials concludes that machines are just as effective at promoting muscle growth as free weights.
For older people, machines may be safer.
There’s been a long-standing debate over whether free weights or machines are superior for building muscle. Free weights require greater stabilization and coordination, while machines provide more stability and may allow you to focus more directly on the target musculature. So does one approach actually produce greater hypertrophy?
A systematic review and meta-analysis by Haugen et al (PMID: 37582807) sought to answer this question by comparing adaptations from free-weight versus machine-based resistance training.
The hypertrophy result: Both free weights and machines promoted similar increases in muscle growth.
There are some important caveats. Only 5 studies met inclusion criteria for hypertrophy, and the methods varied considerably—ranging from ultrasound measurements of muscle thickness to BodPod, skinfold-derived estimates of body composition, and circumference measurements. This substantially limits how confidently we can conclude that the two modalities are truly equivalent across individual muscles and exercises.
Take home: If your primary goal is muscle growth, the current evidence does not support the idea that you need to prioritize either free weights or machines. Both can get the job done. For the gen pop, it’s safe to conclude that exercise selection can be based on factors such as personal preference, comfort, equipment availability, and how well a given exercise targets the muscles you’re trying to develop.
Importantly, the meta-analysis framed the comparison as free weights versus machines, but in practice, it doesn’t have to be an either/or choice. Conceivably, combining the two modalities could provide complementary benefits, as some of the advantages of free weights tend to be limitations of machines, and vice versa. Unfortunately, this possibility has yet to be directly investigated. For now, those seeking to maximize muscle development would seemingly be best-served by incorporating both free weights and machines into their training program. There appears to be potential upside to this approach with little apparent downside. 💪🏽