HD-OPM Archive
Topics › Nutrition

Protein

106 posts (81 primarily about this topic) · 59 reposts and set-aside posts not shown

Start here — the best posts in this topic

  1. Beef and whey raise insulin more than pasta, oatmeal or glucose: use the insulin index ↩ 27 · May 26, 2024
  2. Yogurt has long-term evidence behind it; processed whey supplements do not Jul 09, 2026
  3. Glucose and insulin are different: CGMs show glucose only, and beef or whey spike insulin Feb 21, 2025
  4. Protein type matters more than restriction: whole-food plant protein beats processed meat Nov 12, 2026
  5. Beef and whey raise insulin more than equal-calorie oatmeal, pasta or bread May 09, 2025
  6. Insulin stimulates liver cholesterol production, linking insulin resistance to high LDL Jun 25, 2024
  7. Protein triggers more insulin, so CGM glucose-spike hacks mislead Jun 27, 2025
  8. Nuts and seeds are a healthier alternative to ultra-processed protein powders Dec 12, 2024
#protein 98#proteinsummary 42#plantprotein 27#redmeat 19#whey 19#insulin 18#isoleucine 18#harvard 18#dudleylamming 17#animalprotein 17#muscle 17#insulinindex 16#resistancetraining 16#longevity 16#hns 15#aging 15#proteinrestriction 14#plantproteinsummary 14#igf1 14#dairy 12#mtor 12#fgf21 11#processedmeat 11#methionine 10#hpfs 10#willett 10#valine 9#cgms 8#glucose 8#yogurt 8#sarcopenia 8#influencers 7#oatmeal 7#proteinpowders 7#poultry 7#stuartphillips 7#cancer 6#cheese 6#pasta 5#seafood 5

Beef and whey raise insulin more than pasta, oatmeal or glucose: use the insulin index

May 26, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 23 · 💬 71 ↩ 27 Insulin resistance & diabetes

Louis points out that some proteins are more insulinogenic than carbs: beef raised insulin more than equal-calorie white pasta or oatmeal in the 1997 insulin index study, and whey more than glucose or white bread in a 2012 study. He says influencers have misled people about this and recommends learning the insulin index rather than assuming carbs alone drive insulin.

Protein type matters more than restriction: whole-food plant protein beats processed meat

Nov 12, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 18 · 💬 38

Louis argues against the 'protein craze': there is no good evidence protein restriction slows human aging, but long-term data show whole-food plant protein beats animal protein, especially processed and red meat. Among animal sources, seafood, poultry and fermented dairy have the lowest mortality and processed meat is worst. Plant protein's lower isoleucine, valine and methionine may explain part of it.

Beef and whey raise insulin more than equal-calorie oatmeal, pasta or bread

May 09, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 10 · 💬 41 Insulin resistance & diabetes

Louis explains that CGMs measure glucose, not insulin, and that some proteins provoke as much or more insulin than carbohydrates. Citing the 1997 insulin index paper and a 2012 whey study, he shows beef raises insulin more than pasta or oatmeal calorie for calorie, and whey more than glucose or white bread, so swapping protein for carbs may raise post-meal insulin.

Insulin stimulates liver cholesterol production, linking insulin resistance to high LDL

Jun 25, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 17 · 💬 22 LDL, ApoB & lipid panel

The post explains that insulin signals the liver to make more cholesterol by keeping HMG-CoA reductase active, one reason insulin resistance and metabolic syndrome go with high cholesterol. It argues protein, especially animal protein, also raises insulin, partly offset by glucagon, and that swapping animal for plant protein lowers cholesterol beyond saturated fat and fiber effects. Much of the protein argument is the poster's inference.

Harvard cohorts: plant protein linked to lower CVD and total mortality over 30 years

Sep 16, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 19 · 💬 15

Louis summarizes Harvard Nurses' Health Study and Health Professionals Follow-up Study findings that higher plant protein intake is strongly associated with lower CVD and all-cause mortality over 30 years, whereas animal protein is not, driven by red and processed meat. Seafood and yogurt look favorable. The shared text cites a Rotterdam Study plus meta-analysis of protein intake and mortality.

Whey protein raised insulin about twice as much as glucose or white bread per calorie

May 26, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 11 · 💬 19 ↩ 27

Louis cites a human study in which whey protein raised insulin roughly twice as much as pure glucose or white bread at equal calories. He explains that insulin also drives amino acids into muscle and organs, and fast-absorbing whey raises blood amino acids quickly, so the pancreas responds strongly.

The US leads the world in protein intake, about 1.5 g/kg per day

Oct 28, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 12 · 💬 23 ↩ 8

Louis shares a chart based on FAO data showing the US has the highest total and animal protein consumption, well above the 0.8 g/kg RDA. He estimates about 124 g/day from 3,540 kcal at 14% protein for an 84 kg average adult.

Whey protein raised insulin 90% more than white bread despite 57% lower glucose response

May 15, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 11 · 💬 17

William Wallace shares the Nilsson 2004 trial: in 12 healthy volunteers, whey produced a 90% higher insulin AUC and 57% lower glucose AUC than white bread, tracking plasma branched-chain amino acids. He argues repeated large insulin surges raise IGF1 and mTOR and may have long-term costs, disagreeing with a source that dismisses the concern.

Cutting dietary isoleucine by two-thirds extended male mouse lifespan 33%

Oct 18, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 17 · 💬 11 ↩ 4

Louis shares a Cell Metabolism mouse study in which restricting a single essential amino acid, isoleucine, lengthened life (33% in males, 7% in females), improved leanness, blood sugar, strength and frailty, and reduced age-related cancer. He notes the male effect matches major calorie restriction in mice, and suggests getting protein mainly from whole plant foods, which are naturally lower in isoleucine than animal protein. Mouse data, not proven in humans.

Stuart Phillips: protein past 1.6 g/kg adds little, and longevity gadgets are unproven

Sep 21, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 24 · 💬 16

Phillips says a bit above the RDA helps, more so if you lift or are older, but above 1.6 g/kg per day extra protein does next to nothing. He adds that after 33 years of human research, wellness products sold for longevity have not been shown to extend life, giving examples such as weighted vests and growth hormone.

Red meat and whey raise insulin, countering claims in a Lustig clip

Oct 29, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 13 · 💬 19 Insulin resistance & diabetes

Louis says Robert Lustig and Levels are wrong to imply red meat does not raise insulin. He states red meat raises insulin as much as white pasta or oatmeal and whey more than white bread, so switching from carbs to protein mainly lowers glucose, not insulin. He agrees excess insulin may promote vascular smooth muscle growth and some cancers.

High protein intake linked to higher cardiac risk in adults over 55

Nov 25, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 13 · 💬 12

Louis shares a 2026 cohort study finding that high protein intake may raise CVD risk in older adults and notes it matches 30-year Harvard cohort data on animal protein. He recommends mostly plant protein with some seafood and yogurt.

36 RCTs: extra protein did not boost strength or muscle in healthy adults over 65

Oct 20, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 11 · 💬 11

Louis argues that US adults over 65 already eat over 1.2 g/kg/day of protein and summarizes a 2018 AJCN meta-analysis of 36 RCTs in nonfrail older adults. Added protein did not improve grip or leg strength, walking speed, chair rise or muscle mass, with or without resistance exercise, while exercise itself helped; frail people may differ.

Whey protein raised IGF-1 but not muscle or strength in 24-week RCT of older adults

Jul 18, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 8 · 💬 17

A 24-week placebo-controlled trial raised protein to 1.5 g/kg/day with whey in healthy older adults. It did not improve muscle power, strength, performance or mass, though IGF-1 rose; potassium bicarbonate was also ineffective. Louis argues this means the harms of high IGF-1 without benefit.

Protein type matters more than amount: processed meat worst, plant protein best

Jul 26, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 8 · 💬 17 ↩ 6

Louis summarises Harvard Nurses' and Physicians' follow-up data on nearly 300,000 people over 30 years. Plant protein was protective, fish and poultry slightly so, dairy and eggs neutral, unprocessed red meat slightly harmful and processed meat strongly harmful.

Frailty in older adults is not a protein-deficiency disease, per Luigi Fontana

Dec 19, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 14 · 💬 9

Louis shares Luigi Fontana's argument that frailty and sarcopenia in Western older adults reflect decades of overnutrition and inactivity, not low protein. The post cites randomized trials in which protein supplements gave small or no functional gains, while resistance exercise produced the functional benefit.

Whey protein is highly insulinogenic; Willett wary of powders and IGF-1 cancer risk

Dec 13, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 15 · 💬 10 ↩ 2

Louis argues processed whey spikes insulin more than glucose or white bread and may raise insulin/IGF-1, which promote cancer cell growth. He cites Walter Willett's 2017 book cautioning that protein supplements add little muscle without exercise and that BCAAs increase IGF-1, which may raise breast and prostate cancer risk.

Nurses' Health Study: plant but not animal protein linked to lower frailty in older women

Aug 31, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 10 · 💬 10 ↩ 3

Louis cites a 2022 Nurses' Health Study analysis in older women: higher plant protein intake was associated with lower frailty risk, but animal and dairy protein were not. Substituting 5% of energy from plant protein for animal, dairy or non-dairy animal protein was linked to 38%, 32% and 42% lower frailty risk respectively.

Harvard: swapping red and processed meat for beans, nuts, fish or poultry cuts heart risk

Apr 11, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 13 · 💬 7

Louis quotes the Harvard Nutrition Source: protein source matters more than quantity. Even small regular amounts of red meat, especially processed, are linked to higher heart disease, stroke and mortality, while replacing them with beans, soy, nuts, fish or poultry appears to lower risk, partly because plant proteins are more unsaturated and cholesterol-free.

Midlife plant protein raised odds of healthy aging 22-58% per 3% of calories (NHS)

Aug 31, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 6 · 💬 15 ↩ 7

Louis summarizes a Nurses' Health Study analysis of midlife protein and later-life health. Total and animal protein were unfavorably associated with chronic disease, while plant and dairy protein were favorable. Replacing 3% of energy with plant protein (from fats, carbs, animal or dairy protein) raised odds of healthy aging by 22-58%, and the protein came mainly from food rather than supplements.

GLP-1 drug muscle loss matches calorie restriction: about 25% of weight lost

Mar 01, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 8 · 💬 9 GLP-1 drugs (semaglutide, tirzepatide)

Louis summarizes meta-analytic evidence that lean mass loss on GLP-1 drugs is about 25% of total weight loss, matching diet trials and bariatric surgery, suggesting calorie restriction rather than the drug itself drives it. He cautions higher protein may blunt benefits of calorie restriction in mice, though human relevance is unknown.

Halving dietary protein for 4 weeks did not increase autophagy in human immune cells

Sep 17, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 15 · 💬 4

In a randomized crossover trial of healthy adults, reducing protein from 20% to 10% of calories for four weeks did not significantly change autophagic flux in blood immune cells. Louis concludes that moderate protein restriction alone, without fasting or calorie restriction, does not appear to raise basal autophagy. Caveats include measurement only in circulating immune cells and a short duration; this is a preprint.

Large ICU RCT found no benefit from high-protein feeding; Louis cautions on protein hype

Jun 13, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 6 · 💬 14

Louis shares a post arguing high-protein hype has weak evidence, citing a JAMA ICU trial of 3,397 critically ill patients where higher-protein enteral feeding (100 g/L vs 63 g/L) gave no benefit. It also cites a Nature Reviews Endocrinology paper warning that excess protein might raise diabetes risk and accelerate aging.

Meta-analysis of 69 RCTs: protein strength gains plateau at 1.5 g/kg and need lifting

Jul 26, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 10 · 💬 6 ↩ 11

A dose-response meta-analysis of 69 randomized trials found protein alone does not increase muscle strength without resistance training. With training, strength rose 0.72% per extra 0.1 g/kg/day up to 1.5 g/kg/day, with no further gain; going from the RDA to 1.5 g/kg adds only about 5% more strength.

Six converging evidence lines favor plant protein over red and processed meat

Aug 27, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 11 · 💬 4

Louis shares an Ageproof article by group member Mert Erogul MD arguing that genetics, IGF-1 biomarkers, rodent experiments, amino-acid decomposition, short-term human trials and epidemiology converge: methionine, isoleucine and valine, not leucine or total protein, are implicated. Favoring whole-food plant protein over red and processed meat likely extends lifespan.

Isoleucine and valine fuel prostate cancer by boosting tumor cholesterol

Aug 26, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 7 · 💬 9 Cancer

Louis notes that isoleucine, valine and methionine shorten mouse lifespan, and a 2026 Nature Metabolism study links isoleucine and valine to prostate cancer progression. Their breakdown produces propionyl-CoA, which enhances the cancer cells' cholesterol synthesis, transport and storage, supplying lipids for growth.

Stanford: most Americans already meet the revised 1.2-1.6 g/kg protein guideline

Oct 01, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 6 · 💬 10

A Stanford Medicine piece separating protein hype from science says national data show most adults already consume protein at or above both previous and newly revised recommendations. The poster adds that Americans eat more total and high-quality animal protein than any other major region.

Another large cohort: higher plant protein linked to 35% lower all-cause mortality

Sep 10, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 18 · 💬 3

Louis notes that another large prospective cohort confirms Harvard findings on protein. Higher plant protein intake was associated with 35% lower all-cause mortality, while animal protein showed no significant association. The shared summary adds that the effect likely reflects whole plant foods such as grains, legumes and vegetables.

Six lines of evidence favor whole-food plant protein over red and processed meat

Nov 12, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 12 · 💬 3 ↩ 1

Louis recommends an article by group member Mert Erogul MD on protein and aging. It argues six lines of evidence converge: growth-signaling genetics, IGF-1 biomarker data, rodent protein restriction through FGF21 and mTORC1, the roles of methionine, isoleucine and valine, short-term human trials, and epidemiology showing source matters more than amount. Plant protein from whole foods is favored.

Keto influencer with LDL near 500 mg/dL discovers isoleucine restriction (Lamming work)

Oct 18, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 7 · 💬 6 ↩ 3

Louis comments on a Nick Norwitz video in which a ketovore diet, whose LDL reached 500 mg/dL, is paired with isoleucine restriction. He explains Dudley Lamming's research showing isoleucine restriction extends HET3 mouse lifespan 33% and promotes weight loss, noting animal protein is high in isoleucine and whole plant protein is naturally low. The attachment mentions human data on protein restriction raising energy expenditure via FGF21 (Nature Metabolism).

Whey shake did not curb buffet intake versus a calorie-free drink, challenging satiety

Nov 01, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 8 · 💬 5

Louis, sharing Menno Henselmans, argues protein per se is not more satiating than fat or carbs. A study by Oberoi et al. found a 30 g whey shake did not reduce buffet intake more than a calorie-free drink, and a meta-analysis in older adults found extra protein increased energy intake. Louis says meat satiates because of muscle fiber structure and fat.

High protein intake linked to MASLD in NHANES; amino acids fuel liver fat synthesis

Dec 02, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 4 · 💬 7 Weight, visceral & liver fat

Louis shares a Cell Metabolism study suggesting high-quality protein may drive fatty liver. In NHANES (4,693 participants), carbohydrate and total fat were not associated with MASLD, while medium/high protein intake raised MASLD risk about 1.45-fold and high protein doubled MASH risk; low carbohydrate intake was associated with about 2-fold higher MASH progression. Amino acids serve as carbon sources for liver fatty acid synthesis, and mTOR may play a role.

More protein without resistance training did not improve muscle in older adults

Apr 05, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 5 · 💬 6

In a 24-week factorial RCT of healthy older adults, increasing protein from about 0.85 to 1.5 g/kg/day with whey, with or without potassium bicarbonate, did not improve muscle power, physical performance or mass, though IGF-1 rose. Louis adds it to evidence that extra protein alone does not build muscle.

Valter Longo says higher whole-food plant protein likely protects against heart disease

May 18, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 9 · 💬 3 ↩ 1

Louis notes that Longo, in a podcast, accepts the epidemiology showing whole-food plant protein protects the heart. The rationale is getting plant protein from legumes, nuts, seeds and whole grains without the excess of isoleucine, methionine and BCAAs found mainly in animal protein, which shorten lifespan in animal models.

Review of 33 systematic studies finds little evidence omega-3 supplements build muscle

Mar 14, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 11 · 💬 2 Supplements & vitamins

Louis shares Stuart Phillips' summary of a 2025 Clinical Nutrition ESPEN review of 33 systematic studies, which found little evidence that omega-3 supplements improve lean mass, muscle strength or physical function in healthy adults or clinical groups. Some small benefits in older adults were suggested, but exercise and protein remain the best strategies.

US dietary guidelines panel pushes plant protein, citing Nurses' Health Study papers

Nov 20, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 9 · 💬 2

Louis notes the US dietary guidelines committee is emphasizing plant protein for 2025-2030, partly because of Harvard Nurses' Health Study papers. Those reported that higher midlife protein lowered later-life disease risk only when it came mainly from plants. He advises getting as much protein as possible from legumes, nuts, seeds and whole grains while leaving room for animal foods.

Stuart Phillips preprint: muscle benefit of protein still caps at 1.6 g/kg

Oct 08, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 8 · 💬 1

Phillips posted a new, not peer-reviewed preprint reviewing the evidence and concluding that the muscle-related benefit of protein still tops out at about 1.6 g/kg per day, and only in people doing resistance training. He argues that most trials report lean mass, about half of which is not muscle, and that women's needs are not different from men's.

Protein benefits for muscle plateau near 1.2 g/kg, with no proven gain beyond 1.5-1.6 g/kg

Dec 19, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 8 · 💬 1

Louis summarizes what he sees as the preponderance of evidence: extra protein without resistance training has no proven muscle-strength benefit, and with resistance exercise most benefit is reached around 1.2 g/kg/day. He links a Simon Hill podcast discussing randomized trials and meta-analyses (Morton et al., Tagawa et al.) and a list of earlier group posts.

Whole-food plant protein beats animal protein for long-term outcomes in Harvard cohorts

Mar 30, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 11 ↩ 2

Louis summarizes 30-year follow-up in the Harvard Nurses' Health Study and Health Professionals Follow-up Study: whole-food plant protein is associated with better outcomes, especially for heart disease. The benefit depends on the animal protein type: plant protein is only slightly better than fish, poultry and fermented dairy but clearly better than red and processed meat.

Protein bars and protein shakes produce similar insulin spikes

Jun 04, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 4 · 💬 1

Louis argues that a protein bar spikes insulin as much as a shake, since insulin release tracks blood amino acid levels and both use rapidly digested processed protein. The shared study compared 20 g of milk protein as a bar or a drink in 12 healthy young women.

Isoleucine restriction extended male HET3 mouse lifespan 33% despite higher calorie intake

Oct 18, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 1 · 💬 2 ↩ 4

Louis reposts a summary of the HET3 (Interventions Testing Program) mouse study from Dudley Lamming's group. Mice fed a diet with isoleucine cut by two-thirds from 6 months of age lived 33% longer in males and 7% in females with better health scores, leaner bodies and less cancer, despite higher calorie intake. Louis says this beats rapamycin in males and recommends whole plant protein as a way to lower isoleucine intake.

Protein type matters more than amount: processed meat worst, plant protein most protective

Jun 05, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 4

Louis reshares his summary of protein intake and mortality in nearly 300,000 people followed over 30 years in the Nurses' Health Studies and Health Professionals Follow-up Study. Plant protein was protective, fish and poultry slightly so, dairy and eggs neutral, while unprocessed red meat modestly and processed meat very strongly raised mortality.

Stuart Phillips: 1.6 g/kg/day protein remains sufficient for people who resistance train

Nov 06, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 5

Louis shares a response from protein researcher Stuart Phillips defending the 1.6 g/kg/day recommendation after a critique. He argues it is a sufficiency with a margin, not a cliff, and that head-to-head trials of 1.6 versus up to 3.2 g/kg/day found no significant lean-mass advantage, while three studies cited for more benefit used weak muscle measures.

Calorie for calorie, whey and beef raise insulin more than white bread or oatmeal

Oct 27, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 5

Louis argues excess protein spikes insulin: calorie for calorie, whey protein raises insulin more than white bread or pure glucose, and beef more than oatmeal or white pasta. He criticizes influencers who ignore the insulin index of protein and warns that frequent extra protein keeps insulin high.

Harvard Nurses' Health Study: protein source matters for healthy aging over 30 years

Feb 14, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 2 · 💬 1

Louis shares a video on a prospective analysis of protein intake and aging, calling it the first rigorous long-term human data on protein in middle age and later health. It followed about 50,000 women for 30 years; Louis stresses prospective cohorts are the best feasible design for this question.

Protein restriction and aging: animal benefits, no proven human lifespan gain

Nov 14, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 4

Louis shares a summary of a review (Knopf and Lamming) of protein and amino-acid restriction. Restricting methionine or the branched-chain amino acids isoleucine and valine drives many animal metabolic benefits, FGF21 is involved, but lifespan extension has not been shown in humans. The field is shifting from 'less protein' to which amino acids matter, and older or active adults may need more protein. Louis says protein is complicated and influencers oversimplify it.

Extra protein cannot be stored: the body burns it for energy or converts it to fat

Nov 12, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 1

Louis shares a clip of Stanford's Christopher Gardner explaining that unlike fat, the body has no dedicated storage for excess dietary protein. Surplus amino acids are broken down and used for energy, with carbon skeletons possibly becoming glucose or fat. Adequate protein matters, but more is not automatically better.

Summary of Dudley Lamming's isoleucine restriction research in rodents

Jul 25, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 0 · 💬 1

Louis shares a simplified summary of Dudley Lamming's rodent work on restricting the amino acid isoleucine, linking earlier posts. Human translation is unclear, though some short-term trials of protein restriction show metabolic benefits that might be due to lower isoleucine intake.