HD-OPM Archive
Topics › Protein

Large ICU RCT found no benefit from high-protein feeding; Louis cautions on protein hype

Louis Nervegna · Jun 13, 2025 · ♥ 6 reactions · 14 comments · original Facebook post
ProteinAging & longevity
AI summary & key facts

Louis shares a post arguing high-protein hype has weak evidence, citing a JAMA ICU trial of 3,397 critically ill patients where higher-protein enteral feeding (100 g/L vs 63 g/L) gave no benefit. It also cites a Nature Reviews Endocrinology paper warning that excess protein might raise diabetes risk and accelerate aging.

The current high protein craze is not evidence-based, and may have long term risks.

#proteinHD #igf1HD #mtorHD

Research cited

🚨 The High-Protein Hype: Weak Evidence, Real Risks

Protein is everywhere — in shakes, bars, diet plans, and hospital protocols. It’s marketed as the key to strength, fat loss, longevity, and recovery. But does the science support this “more is better” message?

For example, clinical guidelines recommend augmenting enteral protein during critical illness, but the impact on patient outcomes is uncertain….

🔬 A major ICU trial (3,397 critically ill patients) just tested whether high-protein enteral feeding (100g/L vs 63g/L) improved outcomes. It didn’t.

Paper · JAMAJAMA articlejamanetwork.com

This isn’t just about critical care. High-protein diets are aggressively marketed to the general public — from fitness enthusiasts to older adults — with little outcomes-based evidence.

And here’s the part often left out of the conversation:

⚠️ Preclinical and some clinical studies show that high protein intake may increase the risk of diabetes, and actually accelerate aging and shorten lifespan.

Mittendorfer B, Klein S, Fontana L. A word of caution against excessive protein intake. Nat Rev Endocrinol. 2020;16(1):59-66.

Paper · Nat Rev Endocrinol · 2020A word of caution against excessive protein intake.Dietary protein is crucial for human health because it provides essential amino acids for protein synthesis. In addition, dietary protein is more satiating than carbohydrate and fat. Accordingly, many people consider the protein content when purchasing food and beverages and report 'trying to eat more protein'. The global market for protein ingredients is projected to reach approximately US$90 billion by 2021,…pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Green CL, Lamming DW, Fontana L. Molecular mechanisms of dietary restriction promoting health and longevity. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 2022;23(1):56-73.

Paper · Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol · 2022Molecular mechanisms of dietary restriction promoting health and longevity.Dietary restriction with adequate nutrition is the gold standard for delaying ageing and extending healthspan and lifespan in diverse species, including rodents and non-human primates. In this Review, we discuss the effects of dietary restriction in these mammalian model organisms and discuss accumulating data that suggest that dietary restriction results in many of the same physiological, metabolic and molecular…pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Mechanisms linked to IGF-1 signaling and mTOR activation — both stimulated by high protein — are associated with faster aging and increased risk of chronic disease in animal models.

In contrast, adequate protein intake (especially from plant sources) has been linked to greater longevity in several species and human epidemiological studies.

Bottom line: Protein is essential — but excess protein may do more harm than good. Whether in the ICU or in everyday life, more isn’t always better. Nutrition should be evidence-based, not driven by hype, trends, or industry marketing.

No photo description available.No photo description available.
← newer: Sweetener evidence links: NutriNet-Santé cancer cohort, WHO older: Ornish 1998 trial: plant-based no-oil lifestyle program cut →