HD-OPM Archive
Topics › Protein

Stuart Phillips: protein past 1.6 g/kg adds little, and longevity gadgets are unproven

Louis Nervegna · Sep 21, 2026 · ♥ 24 reactions · 16 comments · original Facebook post
ProteinExercise & fitnessAging & longevity
AI summary & key facts

Phillips says a bit above the RDA helps, more so if you lift or are older, but above 1.6 g/kg per day extra protein does next to nothing. He adds that after 33 years of human research, wellness products sold for longevity have not been shown to extend life, giving examples such as weighted vests and growth hormone.

He tells the truth about what the preponderance of evidence actually shows.

Quoted:

“Protein is my day job, so this one stings. A bit above the RDA helps, more so if you lift or you're older. Past 1.6 g/kg a day the extra does next to nothing (4). More is just more.”

—Stuart Philips

#stuartphilipsHD #proteinHD

It’s all bull. The wellness-optimized seminars, the anti-cortisol lifestyle, the cold plunge, the red light, the instant consult, the peptide sh*t, all of it sold as a way to live longer. I’ve done human research for 33 years. Keep your money.

None of it has been shown to make a human being live longer. A weighted vest worn about seven hours a day for a year did nothing to protect hip bone during weight loss (1). Growth hormone in healthy older adults shuffles a couple of kilos of body composition and hands you swollen ankles and sore joints, and likely you're going to live shorter (2). And that post-workout hormone “spike” people chase (or avoid - cortisol, much?) We tested it in my lab. Nothing for muscle, nothing for strength or muscle (3).

Protein is my day job, so this one stings. A bit above the RDA helps, more so if you lift or you’re older. Past 1.6 g/kg a day the extra does next to nothing (4). More is just more.

Hormones are a different conversation. Got symptoms? Hormone therapy works, and that’s a good reason to take it. It isn’t a longevity drug. Eighteen years of follow-up in the WHI trials and the death rate was no different, hormones or placebo (5). T for women... the latest 'hack' NO DATA

What’s worth chasing is better years. Move most days and lift something. Eat a prudent diet (there are lots of them). Sleep. Turn down the chronic stress. And look after your friends: across 148 studies, stronger social ties came with a 50% greater likelihood of survival (6).

Boring? Completely. It’s also the only part of this that isn’t bull. Nobody gets rich selling it to you, which is why you keep hearing about the vest. Send this to the friend going to teh special access seminar taking the cold plunge.

References: 1. Beavers KM, et al. JAMA Netw Open. 2025;8(6):e2516772. 2. Liu H, et al. Ann Intern Med. 2007;146(2):104-115. 3. West DWD, et al. J Appl Physiol. 2010;108(1):60-67. 4. Morton RW, et al. Br J Sports Med. 2018;52(6):376-384. 5. Manson JE, et al. JAMA. 2017;318(10):927. 6. Holt-Lunstad J, et al. PLoS Med. 2010;7(7):e1000316.

#evidencebased

May be a graphic of money and text that says 'LONGEVITY AND BIOHACKING A COMPLETE AND TOTAL WASTE OF YOUR TIME, EFFORT AND MONEY. What to ignore. Then the five things that work. #NoBSExerciseScience 1/8'May be a graphic of text that says 'THE NOISE x WEIGHTED VESTS x PEPTIDE STACKS x HORMONAL BS x GH BOOSTERS x PROTEIN N x COLD PLUNGES RED LIGHT THERAPY ZERO of these have been shown to make a human live longer or better)... #NoBSExerciseScience 2/8'May be a graphic of text that says 'PROTEIN MAXXING NOISE MORE IS JUST MORE. Protein is my day job. A bit above the RDA helps: 1.2 to 1.6 g/kg a day. Past that, the extra buys you next to nothing. You burn it off and make some very expensive urea. #NoBSExerciseScience 3/8'May be a graphic of text that says 'GH BOOSTING NOISE WE TESTED IT... NOTHING Yes, in my own lab. The post-workout GH "spike" does nothing for muscle or strength. Injected GH in healthy adults? Water weight, sore joints, no added strength. And the longest-lived lab mice are the ones with GH switched off. #NoBSExerciseScience 4/8'May be a graphic of text that says 'HORMONES FINE... IF YOU NEED THEM Hormone therapy treats symptoms, and treats them well. That's the reason to take it. But no data shows hormones make you live longer. The "optimization' clinic is selling a promise with a monthly fee. Cortisol lowering diatribes... FFS?! Complete grifting nonsense! #NoBSExerciseScience 5/8'
← newer: Oatmeal eaters had 21% lower coronary heart disease risk in older: Niacin for CVD prevention: no reason to use it given proven →