HD-OPM Archive
Topics › Brain health & dementia

Experts split over new Alzheimer's definition that includes people without symptoms

Louis Nervegna · Nov 05, 2026 · ♥ 2 reactions · 0 comments · original Facebook post
Brain health & dementia
AI summary & key facts

Louis shares a New Yorker article about the Alzheimer's Association's new definition, which counts amyloid plaques as disease even without symptoms. Experts are divided over whether the definition makes sense and whether early-intervention drugs help. No studies are cited in the shared text.

Link that bypasses the paywall:

archive.isArchived web pagearchive.is

“A new definition of Alzheimer’s includes people without symptoms. Experts are fiercely divided over whether that makes sense—and whether the new drugs really help.”

#alzheimersHD #amyloidHD

Donald Kewman is a 76-year-old grandfather and an active birder. He goes to the gym three times a week, and stays socially engaged. Cognitively, he is not at all impaired. Yet, by some definitions of the disease, he has Alzheimer's. Kewman’s brain contains amyloid plaques, accumulations of a certain protein. A contentious new definition of Alzheimer’s, published recently by the Alzheimer's Association, considers that fact enough to establish the disease. With this understanding, a crop of new treatments propose to intervene early. Still, the medical community remains fiercely divided over whether this new definition makes any sense—or whether the new drugs are effective at all. “The question of where risk ends and disease begins leaves room for interpretation,” Manvir Singh writes. He recounts the long history of Alzheimer's, and reports on the disease’s hotly debated new frontier: Did the World Just Gain Hundreds of Millions of Alzheimer’s Patients? (The New Yorker)

May be a graphic of text
← newer: Walter Willett's daily diet: oats, nuts, salad, whole grainsolder: Calcification paradox: a rising CAC on statins can reflect p →