HD-OPM Archive
Topics › Low-carb, keto & carnivore

Scurvy can occur on a carnivore diet, as a case report of canned-beef eating shows

Louis Nervegna · Mar 29, 2025 · ♥ 4 reactions · 2 comments · original Facebook post
Low-carb, keto & carnivoreSupplements & vitamins
AI summary & key facts

Louis cites a case report showing that a man eating only canned beef and other cooked foods with minimal fresh produce developed classic scurvy. He recovered within weeks on vitamin C 500 mg twice daily. Louis argues that vitamin C needs vary and that fresh meat's vitamin C may not suffice for everyone.

Yes, you can develop scurvy on a pure carnivore diet.

It is documented in the medical literature. See reference below.

Clearly there are some people on a carnivore diet who do actually develop scurvy, even if most do not. Biological requirements for dietary vitamin C vary from person to person. Fresh meat does contain some vitamin C, but this might not be enough for everyone.

The patient in this case report ate a great deal of canned beef, which would have little if any vitamin C compared to fresh meat.

Quoted:

“On further questioning, the patient admitted to a diet consisting only of Bunker Hill canned beef and other cooked foods, with very minimal fresh fruits or vegetables. His constellation of findings was believed to be classic for scurvy and he was discharged on vitamin C supplements (ascorbic acid 500 mg twice a day) with instructions to continue this therapy for life. Within weeks he had made a complete recovery.”

#carnivoreHD #scurvyHDu #vitamincHD

cdn-uat.mdedge.comLink to cdn-uat.mdedge.comcdn-uat.mdedge.com

Research cited

← newer: Six strategies shown to reverse plaque in randomized trials,older: COSMOS: a daily multivitamin slowed cognitive decline by 60% →