The Esselstyn diet can be very healthy, if done correctly. It almost certainly reduces risk for CVD.
I am not disputing this. But I am growing increasingly concerned about people making overhyped claims for this diet that are not backed by credible evidence.
There is an enormous amount of quality science supporting the health benefits of plant-based diets. There is no reason to overhype or hyperbolize this evidence. Let the highest-quality evidence stand on its own for what it truly is.
Caldwell Esselstyn’s published studies are case reports and case series. These kinds of studies are low on the evidence hierarchy in medicine:
↪ Check where a study sits on the evidence hierarchy before citing it
There are major reasons why hyperbolized claims about this diet should be viewed with a degree of skepticism:
theskepticalcardiologist.comThe incredibly bad science behind dr esselstyns plant based diettheskepticalcardiologist.com theskepticalcardiologist.comMore incredibly bad science from dr esselstyns plant based vegan diet studytheskepticalcardiologist.comDean Ornish published the results of a small randomized trial in 1998 testing a WFPBNO diet as a treatment for CVD. The results were very good, but no better than the results seen in large randomized trials of the traditional Mediterranean diet… and no where near the level of the overhyped claims I keep hearing. Not even close. The Ornish trial was also very small— it had only 26 people, including the controls— as compared to thousands in the large trials on the traditional Mediterranean diet.
↪ Ornish trial: lifestyle program cut cardiac events, but plant-based diet was not a cure
↪ Meta-analysis of 4 Mediterranean diet RCTs: MACE down 48%, CVD death down 46%
↪ Lyon Diet Heart Study: Mediterranean diet cut cardiac death and MI 73%, mortality 70%
Credible evidence in medicine comes from the top of the evidence hierarchy, meaning randomized controlled trials and well-done prospective cohort studies. Not from case reports and case series. Those kinds of studies are good for generating hypotheses to be tested later on in randomized trials, but are not a solid basis on which you can make important clinical decisions in medicine. The Esselstyn’s have never followed-up to run such a randomized trial. This is why the vast majority of cardiologists do not recommend the Esselstyn diet, but instead recommend the traditional Mediterranean / DASH diet. (Nor do they typically discourage the Esselstyn diet either.)
↪ Check where a study sits on the evidence hierarchy before citing it
This is a science-based group. There are a lot of other groups where you can make overhyped ideological claims about this diet without corroborating evidence. Not here, please. We hold all diets to that same standard.
You are welcome to share your own personal anecdotes about this diet or any other diet, but please don’t make overhyped generalized claims about diets that go beyond what the published evidence actually demonstrates to be true.



