In light of Baxter Montgomery’s untimely death from a sudden cardiac arrest at 59yo, I am reposting this.
This diet is NOT a magic cure for heart disease.
Louis reposts details of Dean Ornish's small RCT of a whole-food plant-based no-oil diet plus lifestyle changes. Five-year events were lower than in controls, but even adherent patients had heart attacks, procedures and deaths, so it is not a cure.
In light of Baxter Montgomery’s untimely death from a sudden cardiac arrest at 59yo, I am reposting this.
This diet is NOT a magic cure for heart disease.
Below are the results of Dean Ornish’s small randomized controlled trial testing a WFPBNO diet verses CVD (published in 1998).
Note that this was a comprehensive lifestyle program that included other positive lifestyle changes besides just diet.
People on the diet and lifestyle program had considerably fewer cardiac events than controls over a 5 year period (p<0.001).
However, the study clearly shows that a WFPBNO diet was NOT a cure for CVD.
Of the 28 people who faithfully stuck with the WFPBNO diet and lifestyle program for 5 years, there were still:
2 heart attacks (myocardial infarction),
8 angioplasties,
2 bypass surgeries,
23 cardiac hospitalizations,
2 deaths!Some of these numbers are better than controls, but only angioplasties, cardiac hospitalizations, and total events were statistically significant when compared to controls (p<0.05). Heart attacks, bypass surgeries, and deaths were not. In fact, there were 2 deaths in the diet group and only 1 in the control group. This is obviously NOT a cure.
You can read the full published journal paper here:
Paper · JAMAJAMA articlejamanetwork.com chrisjbradshaw.comCan lifestyle changes reverse coronary heart disease Ornish Lancet 1990.pdfchrisjbradshaw.comQuoted from the paper:
“Twenty-five cardiac events occurred in 28 experimental group patients vs 45 events in 20 control group patients during the 5-year follow-up (risk ratio for any event for the control group, 2.47 [95% confidence interval, 1.48-4.20]).”
#ornishHD #wfpbnoHD #ornishtrialHD