HD-OPM Archive
Topics › How to read research

An opinion piece is not a study: judge excess-death claims by the evidence hierarchy

Louis Nervegna · Aug 03, 2026 · ♥ 18 reactions · 74 comments · original Facebook post
How to read researchMyths, misinformation & controversies
AI summary & key facts

Louis responds to a post citing a Japanese paper on excess deaths after COVID vaccination, saying the publication is a speculative perspective piece and not empirical evidence.

THIS IS NOT A STUDY.
IT IS AN OPINION PIECE.

———-

The publication is a speculative opinion/perspective piece rather than an empirical scientific study.

When reading journal publications like this, you need to understand where they fall on the hierarchy of evidence in medicine:

↪ Evidence hierarchy: RCTs and long prospective cohorts sit at the top

Opinion pieces like this aren’t even on the hierarchy at all. They are not studies. They serve to communicate hypotheses that in turn need to be tested in actual studies.

Everyone is welcome to their own opinions, including the authors of this publication. But when it comes to making statements of fact, we use the evidence hierarchy in medicine as our guide to judging whether or not something is true. That’s how this group works.

Please remember that there are over 1.5 million new papers added to pubmed each year. Many of these are opinion pieces like this publication, and not actual empirical studies. Just because something is indexed on pubmed does not mean that it is factually true. You have to use the evidence hierarchy to make that judgement.

Research cited

OK Gokhan Can, your post about Covid Vax saving lives is great, what about excess deaths of those having taken the vax? Here's a large study from Japan. Your thoughts about its validity?

#covid
← newer: The hierarchy of evidence: always ask where a study fallsolder: Get protein from whole plant foods to lower intake of isoleu →