HD-OPM Archive
Topics › Blood vessels, circulation & endothelium

Olive oil's brief FMD dip resembles exercise's transient, hormetic endothelial effect

Louis Nervegna · Jul 02, 2024 · ♥ 19 reactions · 25 comments · original Facebook post
Blood vessels, circulation & endotheliumFats & oils (saturated fat, seed oils, omega-6, olive oil)Exercise & fitness
AI summary & key facts

Responding to Esselstyn's reliance on a short-term study of refined olive oil impairing endothelial function, the poster notes exercise causes the same transient dip followed by rebound. Quoted exercise physiology papers describe an immediate FMD nadir followed by normalization or supranormalization, and he says over 30 RCTs show olive oil improves FMD long term.

Caldwell Esselstyn is fond of quoting a very short term controlled-feeding study that shows refined olive oil transiently impairs endothelial function immediately after consumption.

He conveniently fails to mention that exercise causes this same kind of negative impact on endothelial function in the short term.

These short term stresses to the endothelium from exercise (and presumably olive oil) are believed to be hormetic. They turn on defensive pathways that lead to long term benefits to the arteries. That’s how hormesis works. Multiple studies have shown this. I quote from two of them below.

Over 30 randomized trials in humans have shown that olive oil improves flow mediated dilation (FMD) and endothelial function (EF) in the longer term:

↪ Meta-analysis of 30 trials: olive oil lowers CRP and IL-6 and improves FMD

Quoted:

“In response to acute exercise, vascular endothelial function commonly exhibits an immediate decrease that rebounds back to or above baseline following ~1 h of recovery, although individual responses may vary considerably (18, 19). The immediate decrease in endothelial function following acute exercise can potentially be explained by the concept of hormesis, which posits that the effects of repeated short-term challenges to the system accumulate to produce beneficial adaptations (18, 19). The molecular mechanisms underpinning the potential hormetic response of endothelial function to exercise training are necessary to understand for the development of optimal exercise-based interventions and molecular therapeutics.”

Quoted:

“This synthesis summarizes and integrates knowledge derived from papers relating acute impacts of exercise on artery function, specifically endothelial function assessed by flow-mediated dilatation (FMD). We propose that an immediate decrease in FMD (“nadir”) occurs soon after exercise cessation and that this is followed by a (supra)normalization response. The magnitude of the nadir and (supra)normalization and duration of this biphasic pattern of response appears to be influenced by numerous factors, including the nature of the exercise stimulus (e.g., type, duration, intensity), the subject population (e.g., trained vs. untrained), and various methodological factors. The impact of these factors on the biphasic pattern are most likely mediated through stimuli that underpin altered FMD postexercise, including shear and oxidative stress, changes in arterial diameter, and antioxidant status.”

Paper · Journal of Applied Physiology · 2013Effects of acute exercise on flow-mediated dilatation in healthy humansAlthough the effects of exercise training on vascular function have been well studied, less is known about the effects of acute exercise bouts. This synthesis summarizes and integrates knowledge derived from papers relating acute impacts of exercise on artery function, specifically endothelial function assessed by flow-mediated dilatation (FMD). We propose that an immediate decrease in FMD (“nadir”) occurs soon…journals.physiology.org Paper · J Appl Physiol (1985) · 2019The effects of moderate and high-intensity exercise on circulating markers of endothelial integrity and activation in young, healthy men.Endothelial function typically exhibits a hormetic response to exercise. It is unknown whether endothelial damage occurs in response to acute exercise and could be a contributing mechanism. We sought to determine the effects of acute exercise on endothelial-derived circulating factors proposed to reflect endothelial integrity and activation. Young, healthy men (n = 10) underwent 30-min moderate continuous (MOD) and…ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

#oliveoilHD #fmdHD #endothelialfunctionHD #hormesisHD #exerciseHD #esselstynHD #oliveoilfmdHD

Paper · J Appl Physiol (1985) · 2019The effects of moderate and high-intensity exercise on circulating markers of endothelial integrity and activation in young, healthy men.Endothelial function typically exhibits a hormetic response to exercise. It is unknown whether endothelial damage occurs in response to acute exercise and could be a contributing mechanism. We sought to determine the effects of acute exercise on endothelial-derived circulating factors proposed to reflect endothelial integrity and activation. Young, healthy men (n = 10) underwent 30-min moderate continuous (MOD) and…pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Research cited

← newer: U-shaped mortality curves for LDL, BMI, A1C and blood pressuolder: CORDIOPREV and PREDIMED showed olive oil and nuts caused pla →