HD-OPM Archive
Hashtags

#butter

31 posts

Replacing butter with plant oils linked to 17% lower mortality in 221,054 US adults

Mar 06, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 17 · 💬 68 ↩ 6 Fats & oils (saturated fat, seed oils, omega-6, olive oil)

Louis summarizes a Harvard/Brigham cohort analysis of the Nurses' Health Study, HPFS and NHS II covering over 30 years. Higher butter intake was associated with higher all-cause and cancer mortality, while plant oils (especially olive, canola and soybean) were associated with lower all-cause, cancer and cardiovascular mortality.

Full-fat yogurt lowered ApoB while yogurt with butter raised it in a crossover trial

Apr 02, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 17 · 💬 24 Meat, eggs & dairy

Louis summarizes a randomized crossover study that matched saturated fat in full-fat yogurt versus low-fat yogurt mixed with butter for 4 weeks each. The butter version raised ApoB while full-fat yogurt lowered it, which the authors attribute to the milk fat globule membrane (MFGM) that stays intact in yogurt but is lost in butter. This may partly explain yogurt's favorable epidemiology.

Lyon Diet Heart Study: Mediterranean diet cut cardiac events and deaths about 70%

Dec 12, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 20 · 💬 16 Mediterranean, DASH, MIND & plant-forward diets

Louis comments on a video clip about the Lyon Heart Study, a randomized secondary-prevention trial in people with a prior heart attack. The traditional Mediterranean diet cut cardiovascular events about 70% and all-cause death about 70% over 2.5 years, which he calls the largest total mortality reduction reported in a CVD prevention trial and about twice the benefit of statins in secondary prevention.

Full-fat yogurt lowered ApoB while low-fat yogurt plus butter raised it in a crossover RCT

Jun 07, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 21 · 💬 15 ↩ 1 Meat, eggs & dairy

Louis summarizes a randomized crossover trial matching saturated fat between full-fat yogurt and low-fat yogurt with added butter. Despite equal saturated fat, the butter arm raised ApoB while full-fat yogurt lowered it, which the study attributes to the milk fat globule membrane (MFGM) that is intact in yogurt but lost in butter. He suggests this may partly explain why yogurt looks better than other dairy in epidemiology.

Seed oil intake rose 5x since 1950 while US heart disease death rates fell over 4x

Nov 27, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 18 · 💬 30 Fats & oils (saturated fat, seed oils, omega-6, olive oil)

Louis argues that since 1950 vegetable oil consumption has risen about 5x and butter and lard intake has fallen 2-3x, while heart disease death rates fell by over 4x and life expectancy rose from 60 to 78. He presents the raw unadjusted correlation as evidence against claims that seed oils drive heart disease. It is an ecological correlation, not a controlled test.

Replacing 10 g/day of butter with plant oils linked to 17% lower mortality

Oct 15, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 19 · 💬 13 Fats & oils (saturated fat, seed oils, omega-6, olive oil)

Louis shares Harvard research on 221,054 people from the Nurses' Health Studies I and II and the Health Professionals Follow-Up Study, published in JAMA Internal Medicine. Higher plant-oil intake (especially soybean, canola, olive) was linked to lower total, cancer and cardiovascular mortality, while butter was linked to higher total and cancer mortality; a modeled swap of 10 g butter for plant oils lowered mortality by 17%.

Swapping 1 tbsp butter for plant oil linked to 17% lower cancer and all-cause death

Sep 14, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 17 · 💬 12 Fats & oils (saturated fat, seed oils, omega-6, olive oil)

Louis shares an AHA press release on Harvard cohort data (Nurses' Health Study I and II, Health Professionals) for 221,054 adults. Replacing a daily tablespoon of butter with unsaturated plant oil was associated with lower cancer and total mortality, and each extra tablespoon of butter with higher cancer risk. Olive, canola and soybean oil showed the biggest benefits.

Seed oils don't raise inflammation markers; butter linked to higher mortality

Mar 10, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 7 · 💬 11 Fats & oils (saturated fat, seed oils, omega-6, olive oil)

Louis quotes a news article in which Martha Belury says omega-6 linoleic acid does not significantly change blood inflammatory markers and that the omega-6 to omega-3 imbalance claim is oversimplified. It also reports the Brigham and Women's study of over 200,000 adults for 30+ years: highest butter intake linked to 15% higher mortality, highest plant oil intake to 16% lower.

Butter and cheese affect LDL differently despite similar saturated fat: the food matrix

Sep 02, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 11 · 💬 7 Meat, eggs & dairy

Louis highlights that butter and cheese contain similar saturated fat but affect LDL differently because of food matrix. Churning strips the natural milk-fat wrapper, while in cheese fat stays in a protein mesh, with calcium and fermentation also possibly modifying effects. The shared clip adds that cheese is no free pass given its calories and salt.

Oils are not harmful on a plant-based diet: substitution analyses of olive oil and others

Jun 26, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 5 · 💬 6 Fats & oils (saturated fat, seed oils, omega-6, olive oil)

Quoted explainer addressing the claim that oils are harmful on a whole-food plant-based diet, using substitution analyses. Replacing saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat (oils, nuts, seeds) lowered CHD risk, and olive oil substituted for vegetable oils gave similar outcomes; avocado data from the NHS/HPFS are also cited.

Butter raises LDL and offers no CVD protection; look at the totality of evidence

Sep 30, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 11 · 💬 2 Fats & oils (saturated fat, seed oils, omega-6, olive oil)

Responding to claims that butter is a superfood, the shared post says the butter literature shows neutral to slightly higher all-cause mortality and no CVD protection, and that butter's saturated fat reliably raises LDL-C in controlled feeding trials. Louis adds that conclusions should come from the totality of evidence rather than cherry-picked studies.

Olive oil raised GLP-1 and lowered post-meal glucose versus butter in type 1 diabetes

Olive oil, like all fats, raises GLP-1, and the quoted crossover data suggest it does so more than butter, helping people feel full sooner. After a high-glycemic meal in people with type 1 diabetes, glucose exposure was lower with EVOO than with butter or a low-fat meal, plausibly via slower gastric emptying and glucose-lipid competition.

Swapping saturated fat for polyunsaturated seed oils cut CVD events 29% in strict RCTs

Louis states adipose omega-6 is linked to lower mortality in cohorts, and that RCTs meeting strict criteria (no trans fats, supplied food, 2+ years, biomarker-verified adherence, validated events) show a 29% reduction in heart disease events from replacing saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat. He explains why the Minnesota Coronary Experiment, Sydney Heart Study and Rose Corn Oil Trial fail those criteria.

North Karelia: swapping butter for vegetable oils credited with 80%+ fewer coronary deaths

Louis says replacing saturated with unsaturated fat is believed to be a main reason heart deaths dropped in Finland in the 1970s and 1980s. The shared cardiologist's post describes North Karelia's 700 per 100,000 CVD death rate in 1972, with 24% of calories from saturated fat, and a 20% cholesterol drop with coronary deaths in working-age men falling 82%.

Full-fat cheese raises LDL less than butter, possibly due to the cheese matrix

Oct 29, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 4 Meat, eggs & dairy

Louis shares a summary suggesting full-fat cheese affects LDL less than butter or cream despite similar saturated fat. In a randomized trial full-fat cheese lowered LDL more than reduced-fat cheese supplemented with butter, and another study found cheese eaters excreted more fat in stool than butter eaters. Results are not perfectly consistent and benefits may level off around 50 g/day.