HD-OPM Archive
Topics › How to read research

A 92-year-old athlete's fitness mixes exercise benefit with genetic reverse causality

Louis Nervegna · Dec 06, 2025 · ♥ 12 reactions · 1 comments · original Facebook post
How to read researchExercise & fitnessAging & longevity
AI summary & key facts

Louis comments on a CNN story about a 92-year-old athlete, arguing her health is probably both caused by exercise and a reason she can exercise so hard. He notes many observational exercise studies are inflated by reverse causality and survivorship bias, and welcomes research separating the two.

Her case is almost certainly a combination of both forward and reverse causality.

The exercise is a big part of the reason why she is doing so well at 92. This is the forward causality.

But her genetics (and perhaps other aspects of her lifestyle) are likely a major reason why she is capable of exercising so intensely at 92yo. This is the reverse causality.

Sorting out the relative contributions of each of these directions of causality is one if the reasons why they are doing this study.

Unfortunately, many observational studies on exercise involve a large degree of reverse causality, which inflates their results:

↪ Finnish twin study suggests exercise's mortality benefit is partly reverse causality

Studies in people her age also involve a good deal of what statisticians call survivorship bias:

↪ Centenarians' higher LDL is survivorship bias, not evidence that high LDL is protective

↪ Victorian-diet longevity claim is survivorship bias from excluding deaths under age 5

Most people are not aware of this.

I’m glad scientists are now working to sort this out, so we can quantify precisely the true causal effect that exercise has on longevity in humans.

#exerciseHD #reversecausalityHD #survivorshipbiasHD #longevityHD #agingHD

Shared from CNN · original post

Age is just a number: Emma Mazzenga is redefining athletic longevity at 92 years old, and scientists are trying to figure out how she's doing it.

Read more at the link:

cnn.comAge is just a number: How Emma Mazzenga is redefining athletic longevity at 92 years old | CNNEmma Mazzenga is no ordinary 92-year-old. The Italian is an elite sprinter who has broken multiple world records in track and field.cnn.com
← newer: Ultraprocessed food linked to 45% higher early-onset colorecolder: Oral semaglutide failed to slow Alzheimer's over 2 years in →