When you actually take the time to dig down into the claims made by influencers about VO2-max and longevity, you see that the whole thing is based on a house of cards.
Quoted:
“But when you actually look at the evidence here, you realize that all of this discourse is based on over extrapolation and low quality data by people who are pretending that they have knowledge they don’t actually possess.”
“The Foundational Studies Everyone Quotes on VO2 Max Didn’t Measure VO2 Max
The most cited study in the “VO2 max = longevity” literature is the 2018 JAMA paper showing that low cardiorespiratory fitness carries a mortality risk comparable to end-stage renal disease. Peter Attia references it constantly as foundational evidence for why VO2 max is important.
But the study didn’t measure VO2 max and it didn’t even look at regular, healthy people.
This study took people who were referred for a stress test and then measured performance on a Bruce protocol exercise stress test.
There are quite things to note here:
- How long you last on the Bruce protocol is very tightly linked to the effort you put in - you can’t adjust for that in any analysis.
- Your exercise capacity on this test is not your VO2 max. Of course, they’re related. But they’re not the same thing - it’s a proxy.
- The study didn’t take free-living people and send them for fitness testing. This is a group of people referred for stress test. That’s a very different group of people than folks who are just living their lives and not coming to medical attention. [Poor treadmill performance in unhealthy people often reflects underlying disease—such as chest pain or shortness of breath—rather than just low aerobic fitness. This has nothing to do with VO2-max.]
The problems here aren’t unique to this study.
A huge chunk of the “cardiorespiratory fitness” literature uses exercise stress test duration, estimated METs, or other indirect measures.
Then influencers take those findings and make confident claims about VO2 max specifically.
Most of the foundational studies didn’t actually test the thing everyone is now obsessively optimizing for.”
“The end result: the data simply doesn’t say what anyone is saying that it does
The house of cards logic to the influencer commentary on VO2 max in general and the 4x4 protocol specifically is fascinating to me.
As Andrew Bubak, PhD says, these influencers are the laziest people in science communication.”
My note:
Most of what is mentioned in this post doesn’t matter anyway because mendellian randomization shows zero causality between VO2-max and lifespan: ↪ Mendelian randomization finds no causal effect of VO2-max on longevity or type 2 diabetes.
The point is that even the association is questionable. Forget about causality. There isn't even a proven association. More information on this lack of association can be found in this previous post: ↪ VO2max as a causal longevity metric is doubtful; Mendelian randomization shows no effect.
gregorykatz.substack.comYour VO2 max protocol is based on a house of cardsMediocre evidence meets extreme confidencegregorykatz.substack.com
