HD-OPM Archive
Topics › Exercise & fitness

Mendelian randomization: high VO2max is a health proxy, not a causal driver of longevity

Louis Nervegna · May 14, 2026 · ♥ 11 reactions · 2 comments · original Facebook post
Exercise & fitnessHow to read researchAging & longevity
AI summary & key facts

Louis shares a 2-sample Mendelian randomization of about 70,000 people: genetic predisposition to high VO2max did not predict longevity, but genetic predisposition to low body fat, high muscle mass and high activity did. The same logic applies to grip strength.

Quoted:

“In other words, a high V02max just seems to be a proxy for good health, not a causal driver of longevity. The same can be said for handgrip strength. People with stronger hands live longer because they're generally more muscular and active, not because strong hands are a magic longevity booster.”

Link to the full study:

Paper · J Clin Endocrinol Metab · 2025Cardiorespiratory Fitness, Body Composition, Diabetes, and Longevity: A 2-Sample Mendelian Randomization Study.Conclusion: Cardiorespiratory fitness can be improved by favorable body composition, physical activity, and performance enhancers. Despite being a strong predictor of mortality, VO2max is not causally associated with T2D or longevity.pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Previous posts on this:

  1. ↪ Mendelian randomization finds no causal effect of VO2-max on longevity or type 2 diabetes
  1. ↪ Aging causes VO2max to decline, not the reverse
  1. ↪ Eric Topol: VO2 max is not the same as cardiorespiratory fitness, and claims are overblown
  1. ↪ VO2max as a causal longevity metric is doubtful; Mendelian randomization shows no effect
  1. ↪ VO2-max longevity claims rest on weak, over-extrapolated evidence, argues a critique

#vo2maxHD #peterattiaHD

Research cited

People with better cardio, as measured by a high VO2max, live longer. It's easy to assume that high cardiorespiratory fitness therefore improves longevity, but this relationship may not be causal.

A recent study analyzed the VO2max of ~70k people (with a cycling test) along with their DNA and longevity (predicted from parental survival across generations) based on Mendelian randomization. Since genes are semi-randomly distributed and they increase our chances of having certain traits, such as high VO2max, they function as a natural experiment of whether certain traits causally affect longevity.

Longevity was not predicted by genetic predisposition for a high VO2max, but it was predicted by a genetic predisposition for low body fat levels, high muscle mass and a high activity level, which all correlated with a high VO2max.

In other words, a high VO2max just seems to be a proxy for good health, not a causal driver of longevity. The same can be said for handgrip strength. People with stronger hands live longer because they're generally more muscular and active, not because strong hands are a magic longevity booster.

In conclusion, being lean, muscular and physically active seems to be much more important for your health than having a high VO2max. That's great news for people that don't like cardio, as you can likely get most of the health benefits of cardio from a combination of strength training and a high step count. For optimal health and maximum longevity, I would still do cardio though, because cardio induces more positive adaptations than just a high VO2max.

#vo2max #longevity #cardio #fitness #strength #training #bodycomposition #mennohenselmans #personaltrainer #personaltrainers #personaltraining #personaltrainerlife #personaltraineronline

No photo description available.No photo description available.No photo description available.No photo description available.No photo description available.
← newer: GLP-1 breast cancer survival study reports up to 91% lower molder: Psyllium husk lowers A1C about 0.5% and modestly lowers LDL →