HD-OPM Archive
Hashtags

#whey

22 posts

Beef and whey raise insulin more than pasta, oatmeal or glucose: use the insulin index

May 26, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 23 · 💬 71 ↩ 27 Insulin resistance & diabetes

Louis points out that some proteins are more insulinogenic than carbs: beef raised insulin more than equal-calorie white pasta or oatmeal in the 1997 insulin index study, and whey more than glucose or white bread in a 2012 study. He says influencers have misled people about this and recommends learning the insulin index rather than assuming carbs alone drive insulin.

Beef and whey raise insulin more than equal-calorie oatmeal, pasta or bread

May 09, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 10 · 💬 41 Insulin resistance & diabetes

Louis explains that CGMs measure glucose, not insulin, and that some proteins provoke as much or more insulin than carbohydrates. Citing the 1997 insulin index paper and a 2012 whey study, he shows beef raises insulin more than pasta or oatmeal calorie for calorie, and whey more than glucose or white bread, so swapping protein for carbs may raise post-meal insulin.

Whey protein raised insulin 90% more than white bread despite 57% lower glucose response

May 15, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 11 · 💬 17 Protein

William Wallace shares the Nilsson 2004 trial: in 12 healthy volunteers, whey produced a 90% higher insulin AUC and 57% lower glucose AUC than white bread, tracking plasma branched-chain amino acids. He argues repeated large insulin surges raise IGF1 and mTOR and may have long-term costs, disagreeing with a source that dismisses the concern.

Red meat and whey raise insulin, countering claims in a Lustig clip

Oct 29, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 13 · 💬 19 Insulin resistance & diabetes

Louis says Robert Lustig and Levels are wrong to imply red meat does not raise insulin. He states red meat raises insulin as much as white pasta or oatmeal and whey more than white bread, so switching from carbs to protein mainly lowers glucose, not insulin. He agrees excess insulin may promote vascular smooth muscle growth and some cancers.

NEJM 2020 dairy review: a mixed bag, best for fermented forms, weak for fractures

Jan 23, 2025 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 6 · 💬 21 Meat, eggs & dairy

Louis highlights the widely cited 2020 NEJM review on dairy and disease risk. It concludes that high dairy intake is not supported for preventing fractures, is not clearly linked to weight, diabetes or CVD, and may raise prostate and endometrial cancer risk while lowering colorectal cancer risk. Effects depend on the comparison food: dairy fares better than processed red meat or sugary drinks but worse than nuts.

Whey protein is highly insulinogenic; Willett wary of powders and IGF-1 cancer risk

Dec 13, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 15 · 💬 10 ↩ 2 Protein

Louis argues processed whey spikes insulin more than glucose or white bread and may raise insulin/IGF-1, which promote cancer cell growth. He cites Walter Willett's 2017 book cautioning that protein supplements add little muscle without exercise and that BCAAs increase IGF-1, which may raise breast and prostate cancer risk.

Whey shake did not curb buffet intake versus a calorie-free drink, challenging satiety

Nov 01, 2024 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 8 · 💬 5 Protein

Louis, sharing Menno Henselmans, argues protein per se is not more satiating than fat or carbs. A study by Oberoi et al. found a 30 g whey shake did not reduce buffet intake more than a calorie-free drink, and a meta-analysis in older adults found extra protein increased energy intake. Louis says meat satiates because of muscle fiber structure and fat.

More protein without resistance training did not improve muscle in older adults

Apr 05, 2026 · Louis Nervegna ♥ 5 · 💬 6 Protein

In a 24-week factorial RCT of healthy older adults, increasing protein from about 0.85 to 1.5 g/kg/day with whey, with or without potassium bicarbonate, did not improve muscle power, physical performance or mass, though IGF-1 rose. Louis adds it to evidence that extra protein alone does not build muscle.