HD-OPM Archive
Topics › How to read research

Why diet-health epidemiology may mislead: reverse causation and socioeconomic confounding

Gokhan Can · Jan 15, 2025 · ♥ 15 reactions · 17 comments · original Facebook post
How to read researchLow-carb, keto & carnivoreMyths, misinformation & controversies
AI summary & key facts

Gokhan argues that dramatic personal improvements on low-carb diets undermine trust in guidelines, and that observational nutrition studies can be distorted by reverse causation (people with insulin resistance may prefer fat and protein) and socioeconomic confounding. He says only intervention trials resolve this, and shares a Viva Longevity video on influencers versus epidemiologists reposted by Louis Nervegna. The argument is one-sided.

When people experience dramatic health improvements by doing the exact opposite of official dietary guidelines, it naturally undermines trust in those recommendations. This disconnect is particularly stark in the debate between traditional nutrition advice (exemplified by the food pyramid) and low-carbohydrate diets.

Consider someone who faithfully follows the food pyramid - eating plenty of whole grains and fruits while limiting saturated fats - yet feels chronically unwell. When they switch to a diet rich in foods traditionally labeled "unhealthy" (like cheese, red meat, and butter) and experience remarkable improvements in their health, they're faced with a compelling personal truth that contradicts established guidelines.

While epidemiological studies linking certain foods to poor health outcomes may appear convincing, they potentially overlook two crucial factors:

First, reverse causation: People might gravitate toward certain dietary patterns because of pre-existing health conditions. For instance, individuals with insulin resistance might naturally prefer protein and fat-rich foods because their bodies process them more effectively, rather than these foods causing their health issues.

Second, socioeconomic confounding: Foods often labeled as "unhealthy" tend to be more affordable and convenient. Their consumption might correlate with limited time, resources, or access to fresh, home-prepared meals - factors that independently influence health outcomes.

This raises important questions about the reliability of epidemiological nutrition studies. The true test lies in intervention studies and randomized controlled trials, where confounding variables can be better controlled. Interestingly, when examining actual interventions with ketogenic diets (which are typically high in saturated fats), the results often show positive changes in blood markers and other health indicators - challenging some long-held assumptions derived from epidemiological research.
↪ Video claims paying celebrity influencers for nutrition advice may shorten life

You’re probably shortening your life by paying famous influencers for nutrition advice.

#influencersHD #peterattiaHD #harvardHD

← newer: One zoledronate infusion cut vertebral fractures about 44% oolder: Pomegranate juice and heart health: CIMT, blood pressure and →