AI summary & key facts
Louis pushes back on claims that only vegan diets reverse plaque. He lists the only six randomized diet trials showing plaque reversal (Lifestyle Heart, STARS, SCRIP, PREDIMED, CORDIOPREV, DISCO), all primarily plant-based but none strictly vegan (even Ornish allowed egg whites and non-fat dairy), and summarizes the common foods they emphasized and limited.
- Six trials: Lifestyle Heart (1990, Ornish diet), STARS (1992, AHA diet), SCRIP (1994, AHA diet), PREDIMED (2013, Mediterranean), CORDIOPREV (2021, Mediterranean), DISCO (2021, DASH)
- Emphasized: fruits and vegetables, legumes, whole grains, yogurt, nuts, olive oil, fish, some eggs and poultry
- Limited in all: junk food, refined grains, sugary foods, large amounts of butter, fatty red meat and alcohol
- RCTs sit at the top of the evidence hierarchy and are the only design that can prove causality
I constantly hear people on social media claim that only vegan diets have been proven to reverse plaque.
This is completely wrong.
There have been a total of 6 randomized controlled trials in the history of medicine which have shown reversal of plaque by diet.
All were primarily plant-based, but…
NONE USED A PURE VEGAN DIET
Literally none. Zero.
Even the Ornish trial allowed egg whites, non-fat yogurt, and non-fat milk.
If you eat a pure vegan diet and have gotten good results, that is wonderful. Congratulations! You are welcome to share your story. Lots of people in the group are interested in hearing it, including me. The evidence suggests that it can be a very healthy diet, if done correctly.
But this is a science-based group. Let’s please try to be accurate when making broad scientific claims. Reference the evidence-hierarchy in medicine for what constitutes high-quality scientific evidence: ↪ Check where a study sits on the evidence hierarchy before citing it. Randomized controlled trials are at the very top of this evidence hierarchy, and are the only studies that can prove causality.
There have been 6 randomized controlled trials in humans that have demonstrated that diet can reverse arterial plaque.
They were each successful to varying degrees.
This video goes through each of them, one by one:
Lifestyle Heart Trial (1990) - Ornish diet
Stars Trial (1992) - AHA diet
Scrip Trial (1994) - AHA diet
PREDIMED (2013) - Mediterranean diet
CORDIOPREV (2021) - Mediterranean diet
DISCO (2021) - DASH diet
These are the ONLY randomized diet trials in humans that have ever demonstrated plaque reversal.
The common dietary themes in the trials that worked to reverse plaque were:
- Fruits & vegetables
- Legumes
- Whole grains
- Yogurt, and some other dairy
- Unsaturated fats
- Nuts
- Olive oil
- Fish & seafood
- Some eggs & poultry
Foods that ALL of the trials limited:
- Junk food
- Refined grains
- Cookies, cakes, sugary cereal, sugary drinks, pop tarts, potato chips, etc.
- Large amounts of butter
- Large amounts of fatty red meats
- Large amounts of alcohol
Here are the peer-reviewed journal papers, which show the results of each trial:
Lifestyle Heart Trial (1990)
Paper · JAMAJAMA articlejamanetwork.com
Stars Trial (1992)
Paper · The LancetPII0140 6736(92)90863 Xthelancet.com
Scrip Trial (1994)
Paper · Journal of the American College of Cardiology · 1994Development of new coronary atherosclerotic lesions during a 4-year multifactor risk reduction program: The stanford coronary risk intervention project (SCRIP)jacc.org
PREDIMED (2013)
Paper · Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol · 2014Changes in ultrasound-assessed carotid intima-media thickness and plaque with a Mediterranean diet: a substudy of the PREDIMED trial.Conclusion: Compared with a control diet, consumption of a MedDiet supplemented with nuts is associated with delayed progression of ICA-IMT and plaque. The results contribute mechanistic evidence for the reduction of cardiovascular events observed in the PREDIMED trial.ahajournals.org
CORDIOPREV (2021)
Paper · Stroke · 2021Mediterranean Diet Reduces Atherosclerosis Progression in Coronary Heart Disease: An Analysis of the CORDIOPREV Randomized Controlled TrialBackground and Purpose: Lifestyle and diet affect cardiovascular risk, although there is currently no consensus about the best dietary model for the secondary prevention of cardiovascular disease. The CORDIOPREV study (Coronary Diet Intervention With Olive Oil and Cardiovascular Prevention) is an ongoing prospective, randomized, single-blind, controlled trial in 1002 coronary heart disease patients, whose primary…ahajournals.org
DISCO (2021)
Paper · JACC: Cardiovascular Imaging · 2021High-Risk Coronary Plaque Regression After Intensive Lifestyle Intervention in Nonobstructive Coronary Diseasejacc.org
#reverseHD #mediterraneanHD #dashHD #ornishHD