HD-OPM Archive
Topics › LDL, ApoB & lipid panel

U-shaped mortality curves for cholesterol, BMI, A1C and BP reflect reverse causality

Louis Nervegna · Jun 12, 2024 · ♥ 16 reactions · 24 comments · original Facebook post
LDL, ApoB & lipid panelHow to read researchMyths, misinformation & controversies
AI summary & key facts

A post explaining that U-shaped hazard curves in observational data appear for cholesterol, BMI, A1C and blood pressure alike, and are explained by reverse causality rather than benefit of high values. Illness lowers LDL, BMI, A1C or blood pressure, creating false appearances of protection.

U-shaped curves happen with lots of health-related parameters, not just cholesterol.

This is a very common phenomenon in epidemiology.

You see it with cholesterol, BMI, A1C, blood pressure, just to name a few.

Don’t be fooled by this. The consensus explanation is reverse causality.

Do you really think the optimal BMI is 28, per observational studies? That the optimal A1C is 6 to 8.5, per observational studies? That the optimal systolic blood pressure is 140 to 150, per observational studies?

Of course not.

These look optimal in observational studies because of reverse causality.

For the same reason, the optimal total cholesterol is not 220 to 240.

The charts in the photos below show hazard ratio (risk of dying) for various values of total cholesterol, BMI, A1C, and blood pressure. All of these charts come from observational studies.

The reference for these particular U-shaped charts is this video. They are explained in more detail in the video:

↪ Video: cholesterol and risk of death, new evidence

Note: Reverse causality means that increased risk of dying (e.g. illness) causes the parameter in question to go down. As opposed to the other way around. For example, cancer is well known to cause lower LDL and BMI. Liver or kidney diseases cause lower A1C. Uncontrolled diabetes causes lower blood pressure.

#ushapedcurveHD #ldlHD #a1cHD #bmiHD #bloodpressureHD #reversecausalityHD #cholesterolHD #lowldlHD

← newer: Omega-6:omega-3 ratio does not predict heart disease; nuts aolder: Minnesota Coronary Experiment did not show that omega-6 fats →