HD-OPM Archive
Topics › Protein

Protein type matters more than amount: processed meat worst, plant protein best

Louis Nervegna · Jul 26, 2025 · ♥ 8 reactions · 17 comments · original Facebook post
ProteinMeat, eggs & dairyMediterranean, DASH, MIND & plant-forward diets
AI summary & key facts

Louis summarises Harvard Nurses' and Physicians' follow-up data on nearly 300,000 people over 30 years. Plant protein was protective, fish and poultry slightly so, dairy and eggs neutral, unprocessed red meat slightly harmful and processed meat strongly harmful.

Protein intake and mortality risk

Summary from tracking nearly 300,000 people prospectively for over 30 years in the Harvard Nurses Study I & II and the Harvard Physicians Follow-up Study.

These people were tracked all the way from midlife to old age and death.

The main discovery is that the TYPE of protein matters far more than the AMOUNT.

Plant protein is protective. Poultry and fish are slightly protective. Dairy and eggs are neutral. Fermented dairy (cheese and yogurt) does better than unfermented (milk). Red meat (unprocessed) modestly increases mortality.

Processed meat very strongly increases mortality, much worse than any other protein source by far. And much worse than unprocessed red meat.

Summary:

  1. Processed meat is an unmitigated disaster. The mortality risk is horrible.

Except for trans fats, no food category has worse hazard ratios in high-quality prospective cohort studies than processed meat.

  1. Unprocessed red meat increases mortality risk, but only by a little.

Eating it once a week has little effect on risk.

  1. Fish and poultry confer a small benefit.
  1. The benefit from plant protein is the largest.

The plant protein in these studies came primarily from foods like legumes, nuts, seeds, whole grains, etc… NOT from supplements. We don’t know if these same results would apply to plant protein powders or processed foods that include them, like protein shakes, bars, etc.

Notice that the benefit from plant protein is no where near enough to cancel out the huge harm from processed meat.

(Unfortunately, you can’t cancel out bacon by eating beans.)

  1. Dairy is neutral.

He doesn’t mention this in the video, but when you break out dairy as fermented vs non-fermented in the HNS 1&2 and HPFS, the fermented forms like yogurt and cheese tend to confer a small benefit whereas non-fermented forms tend to show the opposite. When combining both, they tend to cancel out for an overall neutral effect.

  1. Eggs are not mentioned in the video, but these also come out roughly neutral with respect to mortality, in the HNS 1&2 and HPFS.

Reference for video clip:

▶Video · YouTube · TEDx TalksA diet that sustains the planet | Walter Willett | TEDxBostonyoutu.be

#proteinHD #processedmeatHD #redmeatHD #seafoodHD #poultryHD #dairyHD #yogurtHD #cheeseHD #plantproteinHD #hnsHD #hpfsHD #harvardHD #willettHD #proteinsummaryHD #plantproteinsummaryHD

Research cited

← newer: All 25 statin RCTs up to 2016 cut heart attacks and strokes;older: AHA added sugar limits: 36 g/day for men and 25 g/day for wo →