HD-OPM Archive
Topics › Statins

Keto causes bigger temporary insulin resistance than statins, so statin fear is overplayed

Louis Nervegna · Sep 16, 2024 · ♥ 8 reactions · 16 comments · original Facebook post
StatinsLow-carb, keto & carnivoreInsulin resistance & diabetes
AI summary & key facts

Louis argues that keto influencers who fixate on statins slightly reducing insulin sensitivity overlook that a keto diet causes the same effect to a much greater degree. Without carbohydrate, skeletal muscle becomes insulin resistant to preserve glucose for the brain and heart, so a glucose tolerance test on keto looks poor. Both effects are temporary and reverse on stopping.

It is very strange to me that keto influencers are obsessed with the fact that statins temporarily decrease insulin sensitivity by a small amount.

The exact same thing happens on a keto diet, except much worse.

In the absence of carbohydrate, the body temporarily makes skeletal muscle very resistant to insulin in order to preserve precious glucose for the brain and heart. This an ancient survival mechanism that evolved in mammals millions of years ago.

You can prove this to yourself by taking an oral glucose tolerance test while on keto— it will be a disaster. If you give someone on keto a glucose challenge, their blood sugar will immediately skyrocket because their muscles are temporarily blocked from absorbing the glucose.

Statins do the same thing, except by a much smaller amount.

In both cases, it’s a temporary effect.

Stop the keto diet and skeletal muscle insulin sensitivity will return to normal. Same with stopping the statin.

The difference is that the magnitude of the effect is much smaller with statins than with a keto diet. The effect that statins have on an oral glucose tolerance test is tiny compared to the effect that a keto diet has.

If you’re going to argue that a small temporary decrease in insulin sensitivity from a statin is harmful… then to be consistent… you must also argue that a very large temporary decrease in insulin sensitivity from a keto diet is far more harmful.

These influencers obviously do not understand this.

#keto#statins#insulin#glucose#muscle#influencers#insulinresistance#ketoinfluencer
← newer: Economist: gene-editing drugs for cardiovascular disease areolder: LDL particle size does not predict CVD risk once particle nu →